PARLIAMENTARY VOTES
Opposition Motion: Charter for Budget Responsibility (19 July 2016)
Voting Detail By Party
Voted Yes (215 Votes)
Party
Votes
%
Labour
147
68%
Scottish National Party
40
19%
Independent
16
7%
Liberal Democrat
4
2%
Plaid Cymru
2
1%
Conservative
1
0%
Democratic Unionist Party
1
0%
The Independent Group for Change
1
0%
Crossbench
1
0%
Green Party
1
0%
Non-affiliated
1
0%
Voted No (285 Votes)
Party
Votes
%
Conservative
259
91%
Independent
17
6%
Liberal Democrat
3
1%
Democratic Unionist Party
2
1%
Crossbench
1
0%
Labour
1
0%
The Independent Group for Change
1
0%
Non-affiliated
1
0%
Voting Detail (500 Recorded Votes)
Party
Member
Constituency
Voted
Lab
Ms Diane Abbott
Hackney North and Stoke Newington
Yes
Lab
Debbie Abrahams
Oldham East and Saddleworth
Yes
Con
Adam Afriyie
No
SNP
Ms Tasmina Ahmed-Sheikh
Yes
Con
Peter Aldous
No
Lab
Heidi Alexander
Swindon South
Yes
Lab
Rushanara Ali
Bethnal Green and Stepney
Yes
Ind
Lucy Allan
No
LD
Heidi Allen
No
Lab
Mr Graham Allen
Yes
Lab
Dr Rosena Allin-Khan
Tooting
Yes
Con
Sir David Amess
No
Lab
Baroness Anderson of Stoke-on-Trent
Yes
Con
Stuart Andrew
Daventry
No
Con
Edward Argar
Melton and Syston
No
SNP
Richard Arkless
Yes
Lab
Jonathan Ashworth
Yes
Con
Victoria Atkins
Louth and Horncastle
No
Lord Austin of Dudley
Yes
Con
Mr Richard Bacon
No
Lab
Mr Adrian Bailey
Yes
Con
Mr Steve Baker
No
Con
Dame Harriett Baldwin
West Worcestershire
No
Con
Steve Barclay
North East Cambridgeshire
No
SNP
Hannah Bardell
Yes
Con
Mr John Baron
No
Lab
Sir Kevin Barron
Yes
Con
Lord Barwell
No
Ind
Guto Bebb
No
Lab
Baroness Beckett
Yes
Con
Lord Bellingham
No
XB
Lord Benyon
No
Con
Sir Paul Beresford
No
Con
James Berry
No
Con
Sir Jake Berry
No
Con
Andrew Bingham
No
SNP
Ian Blackford
Yes
Con
Bob Blackman
Harrow East
No
SNP
Kirsty Blackman
Aberdeen North
Yes
Con
Baroness Blackwood of North Oxford
No
Lab
Tom Blenkinsop
Yes
Lab
Paul Blomfield
Yes
Ind
Nick Boles
No
Ind
Mr Peter Bone
No
Con
Victoria Borwick
No
SNP
Philip Boswell
Yes
Con
Dame Karen Bradley
Staffordshire Moorlands
No
Con
Lord Brady of Altrincham
No
LD
Tom Brake
Yes
Con
Suella Braverman
Fareham and Waterlooville
No
Con
Sir Julian Brazier
No
Lab
Kevin Brennan
Yes
Ind
Andrew Bridgen
No
Con
Steve Brine
No
SNP
Deidre Brock
Yes
SNP
Alan Brown
Yes
Ind
Mr Nicholas Brown
Yes
Lab
Ms Lyn Brown
Yes
Con
Fiona Bruce
No
Lab
Chris Bryant
Rhondda and Ogmore
Yes
Lab
Ms Karen Buck
Yes
Con
Sir Robert Buckland
No
Lab
Richard Burden
Yes
Ind
Richard Burgon
Leeds East
Yes
Con
Sir Conor Burns
No
Con
Sir Simon Burns
No
Con
Alistair Burt
No
Con
Dr Lisa Cameron
Yes
Lab
Sir Alan Campbell
Tynemouth
Yes
LD
Mr Alistair Carmichael
Orkney and Shetland
Yes
Con
Neil Carmichael
No
Con
James Cartlidge
South Suffolk
No
Con
Sir William Cash
No
Con
Maria Caulfield
No
Lab
Sarah Champion
Rotherham
Yes
Lab
Baroness Chapman of Darlington
Yes
SNP
Douglas Chapman
Yes
SNP
Joanna Cherry
Yes
Con
Rehman Chishti
No
Con
Sir Christopher Chope
Christchurch
No
Con
Jo Churchill
No
Con
Lord Clarke of Nottingham
No
Con
Mr James Cleverly
Braintree
No
Con
Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown
North Cotswolds
No
Lab
Ann Clwyd
Yes
Lab
Lord Coaker
Yes
Con
Dr Thérèse Coffey
No
Con
Damian Collins
No
Con
Oliver Colvile
No
Lab
Rosie Cooper
Yes
Lab
Yvette Cooper
Pontefract, Castleford and Knottingley
Yes
Ind
Jeremy Corbyn
Islington North
Yes
Con
Alberto Costa
South Leicestershire
No
SNP
Ronnie Cowan
Yes
Lab
Neil Coyle
Bermondsey and Old Southwark
Yes
Lab
Ms Stella Creasy
Walthamstow
Yes
Con
Dame Tracey Crouch
No
Lab
Jon Cruddas
Yes
Lab
Lord Cryer
Yes
Lab
Alex Cunningham
Yes
Lab
Mr Jim Cunningham
Yes
Lab
Sir Nicholas Dakin
Scunthorpe
Yes
Ind
Simon Danczuk
Yes
Lab
Wayne David
Yes
Con
Lord Davies of Gower
No
Con
David T C Davies
No
Con
Dr James Davies
No
Ind
Geraint Davies
Yes
Con
Glyn Davies
No
Con
Mims Davies
East Grinstead and Uckfield
No
Con
David Davis
Goole and Pocklington
No
SNP
Martyn Day
Yes
Con
Dame Caroline Dinenage
Gosport
No
Con
Mr Jonathan Djanogly
No
DUP
Lord Dodds of Duncairn
No
SNP
Stuart Blair Donaldson
Yes
Con
Michelle Donelan
No
Con
Steve Double
No
Lab
Jim Dowd
Yes
Lab
Peter Dowd
Bootle
Yes
Con
Sir Oliver Dowden
Hertsmere
No
Con
Dame Jackie Doyle-Price
No
Con
Richard Drax
No
Lab
Jack Dromey
Yes
Con
Mrs Flick Drummond
No
Con
Sir James Duddridge
No
Con
Sir Iain Duncan Smith
Chingford and Woodford Green
No
Con
Philip Dunne
No
Ind
Jonathan Edwards
Yes
Lab
Clive Efford
Eltham and Chislehurst
Yes
Lab
Julie Elliott
Yes
Con
Sir Michael Ellis
No
Con
Jane Ellison
No
Ind
Dame Louise Ellman
Yes
Ind
Charlie Elphicke
No
Con
Lord Evans of Rainow
No
Con
Mr Nigel Evans
No
Con
Sir David Evennett
No
Con
Michael Fabricant
No
Lab
Paul Farrelly
Yes
SNP
Marion Fellows
Yes
Ind
Margaret Ferrier
Yes
Con
Mark Field
No
Lab
Jim Fitzpatrick
Yes
Lab
Colleen Fletcher
Yes
Lab
Paul Flynn
Yes
Lab
Yvonne Fovargue
Yes
Con
Sir Liam Fox
No
Lab
Vicky Foxcroft
Lewisham North
Yes
Con
Mr Mark Francois
Rayleigh and Wickford
No
Con
Lucy Frazer
No
Con
George Freeman
Mid Norfolk
No
Con
Mike Freer
No
Lab
Gill Furniss
Sheffield Brightside and Hillsborough
Yes
Con
Mr Marcus Fysh
No
Con
Sir Roger Gale
Herne Bay and Sandwich
No
Lab
Barry Gardiner
Brent West
Yes
Con
Lord Garnier
No
Con
Mark Garnier
Wyre Forest
No
Ind
Mr David Gauke
No
SNP
Stephen Gethins
Arbroath and Broughty Ferry
Yes
Con
Ms Nusrat Ghani
Sussex Weald
No
Con
Nick Gibb
No
SNP
Patricia Gibson
Yes
Con
Dame Cheryl Gillan
No
Lab
Pat Glass
Yes
Con
John Glen
Salisbury
No
Lab
Mary Glindon
Newcastle upon Tyne East and Wallsend
Yes
Lab
Mr Roger Godsiff
Yes
Con
Lord Goldsmith of Richmond Park
No
Lab
Helen Goodman
Yes
Con
Sir Robert Goodwill
No
Con
Michael Gove
No
SNP
Patrick Grady
Yes
Con
Richard Graham
No
Con
Helen Grant
Maidstone and Malling
No
SNP
Peter Grant
Yes
Con
James Gray
No
SNP
Neil Gray
Yes
Con
Lord Grayling
No
Lab
Kate Green
Yes
Ind
Justine Greening
No
Lab
Lilian Greenwood
Nottingham South
Yes
Lab
Margaret Greenwood
Yes
Ind
Mr Dominic Grieve
No
Lab
Dame Nia Griffith
Llanelli
Yes
Con
Andrew Griffiths
No
Con
Ben Gummer
No
Lab
Andrew Gwynne
Gorton and Denton
Yes
Lab
Louise Haigh
Sheffield Heeley
Yes
Con
Robert Halfon
No
Con
Luke Hall
No
Lab
Fabian Hamilton
Leeds North East
Yes
Con
Stephen Hammond
No
Con
Matt Hancock
No
Con
Greg Hands
No
Lab
Lord Hanson of Flint
Yes
Lab
Baroness Harman
Yes
Con
Mr Mark Harper
No
Lab
Carolyn Harris
Neath and Swansea East
Yes
Con
Rebecca Harris
Castle Point
No
Con
Simon Hart
No
Con
Lord Haselhurst
No
Lab
Helen Hayes
Dulwich and West Norwood
Yes
Lab
Baroness Hayman of Ullock
Yes
Con
Sir Oliver Heald
No
Lab
John Healey
Rawmarsh and Conisbrough
Yes
Con
James Heappey
No
Con
Peter Heaton-Jones
No
Con
Gordon Henderson
No
SNP
Drew Hendry
Yes
Ind
Mr Stephen Hepburn
Yes
Con
Lord Herbert of South Downs
No
Con
Damian Hinds
East Hampshire
No
Con
Simon Hoare
North Dorset
No
Lab
Mrs Sharon Hodgson
Washington and Gateshead South
Yes
Lab
Kate Hollern
Yes
Con
Sir George Hollingbery
No
Con
Kevin Hollinrake
Thirsk and Malton
No
Con
Adam Holloway
No
Ind
Kelvin Hopkins
Yes
SNP
Stewart Hosie
Yes
Lab
Sir George Howarth
Yes
Con
Sir Gerald Howarth
No
Con
John Howell
No
Con
Ben Howlett
No
Con
Nigel Huddleston
Droitwich and Evesham
No
Con
Jeremy Hunt
Godalming and Ash
No
Lab
Dr Rupa Huq
Ealing Central and Acton
Yes
Con
Lord Jackson of Peterborough
No
Con
Margot James
No
Con
Sir Sajid Javid
No
Con
Mr Ranil Jayawardena
No
Con
Sir Bernard Jenkin
Harwich and North Essex
No
Con
Dame Andrea Jenkyns
No
Con
Robert Jenrick
Newark
No
Con
Lord Johnson of Marylebone
No
Lab
Alan Johnson
Yes
Lab
Dame Diana Johnson
Kingston upon Hull North and Cottingham
Yes
Con
Gareth Johnson
No
Con
Andrew Jones
No
Lab
Gerald Jones
Merthyr Tydfil and Aberdare
Yes
Lab
Graham P Jones
Yes
Con
Mr David Jones
No
Con
Mr Marcus Jones
No
Lab
Susan Elan Jones
Yes
Lab
Mike Kane
Wythenshawe and Sale East
Yes
Con
Daniel Kawczynski
No
Con
Seema Kennedy
No
Lab
Stephen Kinnock
Aberafan Maesteg
Yes
Con
Simon Kirby
No
Ind
Julian Knight
No
Con
Kwasi Kwarteng
No
Lab
Peter Kyle
Hove and Portslade
Yes
LD
Norman Lamb
Yes
Lab
Mr David Lammy
Tottenham
Yes
Con
Lord Lancaster of Kimbolton
No
Con
Mrs Pauline Latham
No
Lab
Ian Lavery
Blyth and Ashington
Yes
SNP
Chris Law
Dundee Central
Yes
Con
Andrea Leadsom
No
LD
Dr Phillip Lee
No
Con
Jeremy Lefroy
No
Con
Sir Edward Leigh
Gainsborough
No
Ind
Sir Oliver Letwin
No
Lab
Mrs Emma Lewell-Buck
South Shields
Yes
Lab
Clive Lewis
Norwich South
Yes
Con
Sir Brandon Lewis
No
Con
Sir Julian Lewis
New Forest East
No
Con
Mr Ian Liddell-Grainger
No
Con
Sir David Lidington
No
Con
Lord Lilley
No
Ind
Rebecca Long Bailey
Salford
Yes
Con
Jack Lopresti
No
Con
Mr Jonathan Lord
No
Green
Caroline Lucas
Yes
Con
Karen Lumley
No
Lab
Holly Lynch
Yes
Con
Lord Mackinlay of Richborough
No
Con
David Mackintosh
No
Lab
Justin Madders
Ellesmere Port and Bromborough
Yes
Lab
Mr Khalid Mahmood
Yes
Con
Mrs Anne Main
No
Con
Alan Mak
Havant
No
Lab
Seema Malhotra
Feltham and Heston
Yes
Con
Kit Malthouse
North West Hampshire
No
Lab
Lord Mann
Yes
Con
Scott Mann
No
Lab
Gordon Marsden
Yes
Lab
Rachael Maskell
York Central
Yes
Ind
Christian Matheson
Yes
Con
Dr Tania Mathias
No
Con
Paul Maynard
No
Lab
Steve McCabe
Yes
SNP
Callum McCaig
Yes
Lab
Kerry McCarthy
Bristol East
Yes
Con
Karl McCartney
No
Lab
Dame Siobhain McDonagh
Mitcham and Morden
Yes
SNP
Stewart Malcolm McDonald
Yes
SNP
Stuart C McDonald
Yes
Ind
John McDonnell
Hayes and Harlington
Yes
Ind
Conor McGinn
Yes
Lab
Alison McGovern
Birkenhead
Yes
Lab
Liz McInnes
Yes
SNP
Anne McLaughlin
Yes
Con
Lord McLoughlin
No
Con
Stephen McPartland
No
Lab
Sir Alan Meale
Yes
Lab
Ian Mearns
Yes
Con
Johnny Mercer
No
Con
Huw Merriman
No
Con
Stephen Metcalfe
No
Lab
Ed Miliband
Doncaster North
Yes
Con
Dame Maria Miller
No
Con
Dame Amanda Milling
No
Con
Nigel Mills
No
Ind
Anne Milton
No
Con
Mr Andrew Mitchell
Sutton Coldfield
No
Con
Penny Mordaunt
No
Lab
Jessica Morden
Newport East
Yes
Con
Anne Marie Morris
No
Con
David Morris
No
Lab
Grahame Morris
Easington
Yes
Con
James Morris
No
Con
Wendy Morton
Aldridge-Brownhills
No
Con
David Mowat
No
LD
Greg Mulholland
Yes
SNP
Roger Mullin
Yes
Con
David Mundell
Dumfriesshire, Clydesdale and Tweeddale
No
Lab
Ian Murray
Edinburgh South
Yes
Con
Mrs Sheryll Murray
No
Con
Dr Andrew Murrison
South West Wiltshire
No
Lab
Lisa Nandy
Wigan
Yes
Con
Sir Robert Neill
No
SNP
Gavin Newlands
Yes
Con
Sarah Newton
No
SNP
John Nicolson
Yes
Con
Caroline Nokes
Romsey and Southampton North
No
Con
Jesse Norman
Hereford and South Herefordshire
No
Con
Mr David Nuttall
No
SNP
Brendan O'Hara
Argyll, Bute and South Lochaber
Yes
Con
Dr Matthew Offord
No
Lab
Melanie Onn
Great Grimsby and Cleethorpes
Yes
Lab
Chi Onwurah
Newcastle upon Tyne Central and West
Yes
Con
Guy Opperman
No
Lab
Kate Osamor
Edmonton and Winchmore Hill
Yes
SNP
Kirsten Oswald
Yes
Con
Neil Parish
No
Con
Priti Patel
Witham
No
Con
Mr Owen Paterson
No
SNP
Steven Paterson
Yes
Con
Mark Pawsey
No
Lab
Teresa Pearce
Yes
Con
Sir Mike Penning
No
Lab
Matthew Pennycook
Greenwich and Woolwich
Yes
Con
John Penrose
No
Con
Andrew Percy
No
Con
Claire Perry
No
Lab
Jess Phillips
Birmingham Yardley
Yes
Con
Stephen Phillips
No
Lab
Bridget Phillipson
Houghton and Sunderland South
Yes
Con
Chris Philp
Croydon South
No
Con
Lord Pickles
No
Ind
Christopher Pincher
No
Lab
Dr Dan Poulter
No
Con
Rebecca Pow
No
Lab
Lucy Powell
Manchester Central
Yes
Con
Mr Mark Prisk
No
Con
Mark Pritchard
The Wrekin
No
Con
Tom Pursglove
No
Con
Sir Jeremy Quin
No
Con
Will Quince
No
Con
Dominic Raab
No
Lab
Angela Rayner
Ashton-under-Lyne
Yes
Con
Sir John Redwood
No
Lab
Mr Jamie Reed
Yes
Lab
Steve Reed
Streatham and Croydon North
Yes
Lab
Christina Rees
Yes
Con
Sir Jacob Rees-Mogg
No
Lab
Jonathan Reynolds
Stalybridge and Hyde
Yes
Lab
Ms Marie Rimmer
St Helens South and Whiston
Yes
Lab
Baroness Ritchie of Downpatrick
Yes
SNP
Angus Robertson
Yes
Con
Mr Laurence Robertson
No
DUP
Gavin Robinson
Belfast East
No
Con
Mary Robinson
No
Lab
Mr Geoffrey Robinson
Yes
Con
Andrew Rosindell
Romford
No
Lab
Steve Rotheram
Yes
Ind
Amber Rudd
No
Con
David Rutley
No
IGC
Joan Ryan
Yes
SNP
Alex Salmond
Yes
LD
Antoinette Sandbach
No
PC
Liz Saville Roberts
Dwyfor Meirionnydd
Yes
Con
Paul Scully
No
Con
Andrew Selous
No
Lab
Naz Shah
Bradford West
Yes
DUP
Jim Shannon
Strangford
Yes
Con
Grant Shapps
No
Con
Lord Sharma
No
Lab
Mr Virendra Sharma
Yes
Lab
Mr Barry Sheerman
Yes
Con
Sir Alec Shelbrooke
Wetherby and Easingwold
No
Lab
Paula Sherriff
Yes
Ind
Mr Gavin Shuker
Yes
Lab
Tulip Siddiq
Hampstead and Highgate
Yes
Con
Mr Keith Simpson
No
Con
Chris Skidmore
No
Lab
Mr Dennis Skinner
Yes
Lab
Andy Slaughter
Hammersmith and Chiswick
Yes
Lab
Cat Smith
Lancaster and Wyre
Yes
Con
Chloe Smith
No
Con
Henry Smith
No
Lab
Jeff Smith
Manchester Withington
Yes
Lab
Mr Andrew Smith
Yes
Lab
Nick Smith
Blaenau Gwent and Rhymney
Yes
Lab
Owen Smith
Yes
Con
Royston Smith
No
Con
Sir Julian Smith
Skipton and Ripon
No
Con
Lord Soames of Fletching
No
Con
Amanda Solloway
No
IGC
Anna Soubry
No
Lab
Lord Spellar
Yes
Con
Dame Caroline Spelman
No
Con
Sir Mark Spencer
No
SNP
Chris Stephens
Yes
Con
Andrew Stephenson
No
Lab
Jo Stevens
Cardiff East
Yes
Con
John Stevenson
No
Con
Bob Stewart
No
Ind
Rory Stewart
No
Con
Sir Gary Streeter
No
Lab
Wes Streeting
Ilford North
Yes
Con
Mel Stride
Central Devon
No
XB
Baroness Stuart of Edgbaston
Yes
Con
Graham Stuart
Beverley and Holderness
No
Con
Julian Sturdy
No
Con
Rishi Sunak
Richmond and Northallerton
No
Con
Sir Desmond Swayne
New Forest West
No
Con
Sir Robert Syms
No
Lab
Mark Tami
Alyn and Deeside
Yes
SNP
Alison Thewliss
Yes
Con
Derek Thomas
No
Lab
Gareth Thomas
Harrow West
Yes
Lab
Nick Thomas-Symonds
Torfaen
Yes
SNP
Owen Thompson
Yes
Ind
Michelle Thomson
Yes
Lab
Emily Thornberry
Islington South and Finsbury
Yes
Con
Maggie Throup
No
Lab
Sir Stephen Timms
East Ham
Yes
Con
Edward Timpson
No
Con
Kelly Tolhurst
No
Con
Justin Tomlinson
No
Con
Michael Tomlinson
No
Con
Craig Tracey
No
Con
Anne-Marie Trevelyan
No
Lab
Jon Trickett
Normanton and Hemsworth
Yes
Con
Elizabeth Truss
No
Con
Tom Tugendhat
Tonbridge
No
Lab
Anna Turley
Redcar
Yes
Lab
Karl Turner
Kingston upon Hull East
Yes
Con
Mr Andrew Turner
No
Lab
Stephen Twigg
Yes
Lord Tyrie
No
Con
Lord Vaizey of Didcot
No
Con
Shailesh Vara
No
Lab
Keith Vaz
Yes
Con
Martin Vickers
Brigg and Immingham
No
Con
Theresa Villiers
No
Con
Mr Robin Walker
No
Con
Sir Charles Walker
No
Con
Mr Ben Wallace
No
Ind
David Warburton
No
Con
Matt Warman
No
Lab
Lord Watson of Wyre Forest
Yes
SNP
Mike Weir
Yes
Lab
Catherine West
Hornsey and Friern Barnet
Yes
Con
Lord Wharton of Yarm
No
Con
Helen Whately
Faversham and Mid Kent
No
Con
Mrs Heather Wheeler
No
Con
Chris White
No
Lab
Dr Alan Whitehead
Yes
SNP
Dr Philippa Whitford
Yes
Con
Craig Whittaker
No
Con
Sir John Whittingdale
Maldon
No
Con
Sir Bill Wiggin
No
Con
Craig Williams
No
PC
Hywel Williams
Yes
Con
Sir Gavin Williamson
Stone, Great Wyrley and Penkridge
No
Con
Mr Rob Wilson
No
Lab
Mr David Winnick
Yes
Lab
Baroness Winterton of Doncaster
Yes
SNP
Pete Wishart
Perth and Kinross-shire
Yes
Con
Mike Wood
Kingswinford and South Staffordshire
No
Ind
Mr William Wragg
No
Lab
Mr Iain Wright
Yes
Con
Sir Jeremy Wright
Kenilworth and Southam
No
Con
Nadhim Zahawi
No
Lab
Daniel Zeichner
Cambridge
Yes
Notes
Members highlighted in bold acted as tellers for this vote.
Contains Parliamentary information licensed under the Open Parliament Licence v3.0.