PARLIAMENTARY EARLY DAY MOTION
ALZHEIMER'S AND NATIONAL INSTITUTE FOR HEALTH AND CLINICAL EXCELLENCE DECISION (20 July 2005)

Motion Details

That this House expresses its deep concern that the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) appraisal committee has rejected the responses to the consultation on Alzheimer's drugs and has not yet approved prescription of these drugs on the NHS; believes that these drugs are both clinically and cost effective; notes that NICE agrees that the drugs provide clinical benefits; further notes that the average cost of treatment is £2.50 per day; further notes that thousands of people with dementia and their carers have made representations to NICE that these drugs improve quality of life; further notes that an alliance of leading patient and professional organisations in dementia care and research has been launched to campaign for fair access to drug treatments for people with dementia on the NHS; agrees with the Action on Alzheimer's Drugs Alliance that effective drug treatments for Alzheimer's disease should be available on the NHS; fears that NICE has failed to consider the important concerns raised by the Department of Health about its draft guidance; and calls upon the Government to ensure that these concerns are addressed.

Sponsored by:
Martin Horwood (Liberal Democrat)

EDMS Sponsor By Party

Party
Votes
%
 
Labour
101
47%
 
 
Conservative
46
21%
 
 
Liberal Democrat
41
19%
 
 
Independent
15
7%
 
 
Democratic Unionist Party
3
1%
 
 
Speaker
2
1%
 
 
Non-affiliated
2
1%
 
 
Not Available
2
1%
 
 
Plaid Cymru
2
1%
 
 
Social Democratic & Labour Party
2
1%
 
 
Crossbench
1
0%
 
Sponsor List (217 sponsors)
Party
Member
Constituency
Lab
Ms Diane Abbott
Hackney North and Stoke Newington
Lab
Janet Anderson
Lab
Mr David Anderson
Con
Mr Peter Atkinson
Lord Austin of Dudley
Con
Sir Tony Baldry
Lab
Ms Celia Barlow
LD
John Barrett
Lab
John Battle
Lab
Lord Beamish
Lab
Dame Anne Begg
LD
Lord Beith
Spk
John Bercow
Lab
Roger Berry
Lab
Mr Clive Betts
Sheffield South East
Lab
Dr Roberta Blackman-Woods
Lab
Mr David S. Borrow
Con
Sir Peter Bottomley
LD
Tom Brake
LD
Mr Colin Breed
Con
James Brokenshire
LD
Annette Brooke
Ind
Mr Nicholas Brown
Lab
Mr Russell Brown
Lab
Ms Lyn Brown
LD
Mr Jeremy Browne
Lab
Richard Burden
Lab
Colin Burgon
Con
Sir Simon Burns
Con
Mr David Burrowes
LD
Baroness Burt of Solihull
Con
Sir John Butterfill
DUP
Mr Gregory Campbell
East Londonderry
Ind
Mr Douglas Carswell
Lab
Martin Caton
Lab
Colin Challen
Lab
Ben Chapman
Ind
Mr David Chaytor
Lab
Mr Michael Clapham
Con
Greg Clark
LD
Mr Nick Clegg
Lab
Mr David Clelland
Lab
Harry Cohen
Lab
Michael Connarty
Derek Conway
Lab
Rosie Cooper
Lab
Jim Cousins
Con
Stephen Crabb
Lab
Mary Creagh
Coventry East
Lab
Jon Cruddas
Lab
Mr Jim Cunningham
Lab
Mrs Claire Curtis-Thomas
Ind
Mr Dai Davies
Con
Sir Philip Davies
Lab
Mrs Janet Dean
Lab
Mr Jim Devine
Lab
Jim Dobbin
DUP
Lord Dodds of Duncairn
Ind
Sir Jeffrey M Donaldson
Con
Ms Nadine Dorries
Lab
Dr David Drew
SDLP
Mark Durkan
Lab
Clive Efford
Eltham and Chislehurst
Con
Mr Tobias Ellwood
Lab
Jeff Ennis
Lab
Bill Etherington
Con
Mr Nigel Evans
Con
Sir Michael Fallon
LD
Tim Farron
Westmorland and Lonsdale
LD
Baroness Featherstone
XB
Lord Field of Birkenhead
Lab
Mark Fisher
Lab
Paul Flynn
LD
Lord Foster of Bath
Lab
Michael Jabez Foster
Lab
Dr Hywel Francis
LD
Andrew George
St Ives
Lab
Mr Bruce George
LD
Sandra Gidley
Lab
Mr Roger Godsiff
LD
Julia Goldsworthy
Lab
Helen Goodman
Con
Sir Robert Goodwill
Con
Michael Gove
Con
Mr John Greenway
Lab
John Grogan
Lab
Fabian Hamilton
Leeds North East
Lab
Mr David Hamilton
Con
Stephen Hammond
Ind
Mr Mike Hancock
Con
Greg Hands
LD
Sir Nick Harvey
Lab
Mr Dai Havard
LD
John Hemming
Lab
Mr Doug Henderson
Ind
Mr Stephen Hepburn
Ind
Lady Hermon
Lab
David Heyes
Lab
Mrs Sharon Hodgson
Washington and Gateshead South
Baroness Hoey
LD
Paul Holmes
Ind
Kelvin Hopkins
LD
Martin Horwood (Sponsor)
LD
David Howarth
Lab
Sir George Howarth
Spk
Sir Lindsay Hoyle
Chorley
LD
Simon Hughes
LD
Chris Huhne
Lab
Mrs Joan Humble
LD
Mark Hunter
Con
Mr Michael Jack
Con
Lord Jackson of Peterborough
Lab
Dame Diana Johnson
Kingston upon Hull North and Cottingham
Lab
Lynne Jones
Con
Mr David Jones
Lab
Ms Sally Keeble
Lab
Baroness Keeley
Lab
Alan Keen
LD
Mr Paul Keetch
Lab
Mr Fraser Kemp
Con
Robert Key
Lab
Mr Piara S Khabra
Lab
Sadiq Khan
Con
Mrs Jacqui Lait
LD
Norman Lamb
Lab
Mr Bob Laxton
LD
Mr John Leech
Lab
David Lepper
Con
Lord Lilley
Lab
Tony Lloyd
PC
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
Con
Sir Peter Luff
Con
Mr Andrew Mackay
Lab
Judy Mallaber
Lab
Rob Marris
Lab
Gordon Marsden
Lab
Mr Robert Marshall-Andrews
Con
Mr Michael Mates
Lab
Chris McCafferty
Lab
Sarah McCarthy-Fry
SDLP
Dr Alasdair McDonnell
Ind
John McDonnell
Hayes and Harlington
Lab
Sir Alan Meale
Lab
Andrew Miller
Con
Dame Maria Miller
Ind
Anne Milton
Lab
Austin Mitchell
Lab
Anne Moffat
Lab
Julie Morgan
Lab
Mr George Mudie
LD
Greg Mulholland
Lab
Lord Murphy of Torfaen
Lab
Mr Denis Murphy
Con
Mr Brooks Newmark
Lab
Mr Edward O'Hara
LD
Mr Mark Oaten
LD
Lembit Öpik
Con
Sir Richard Ottaway
Lab
Albert Owen
Ind
Mr Andrew Pelling
Con
Sir Mike Penning
Lab
Mr Greg Pope
Lab
Mr Gordon Prentice
PC
Adam Price
Con
Mark Pritchard
The Wrekin
LD
John Pugh
Con
Lord Randall of Uxbridge
Lab
Mr Jamie Reed
Ind
Mrs Iris Robinson
LD
Dan Rogerson
Lab
Dame Joan Ruddock
LD
Sir Bob Russell
Lab
Martin Salter
LD
Mr Adrian Sanders
Con
Grant Shapps
Clare Short
Lab
Alan Simpson
DUP
David Simpson
Lab
Mr Marsha Singh
Lab
Mr Dennis Skinner
Lab
John Smith
Lab
Sir Peter Soulsby
Ind
Bob Spink
Lab
Dr Howard Stoate
Con
Graham Stuart
Beverley and Holderness
LD
Lord Stunell
LD
Lord Taylor of Goss Moor
Lab
David Taylor
Con
Mr Ian Taylor
LD
Sarah Teather
Lab
Emily Thornberry
Islington South and Finsbury
Lab
Paddy Tipping
Lab
Mr Paul Truswell
Lab
Dr Desmond Turner
Con
Lord Vaizey of Didcot
Lab
Keith Vaz
Con
Sir Peter Viggers
Lab
Dr Rudi Vis
Lab
Joan Walley
Con
Mr Robert Walter
Ind
Mr Robert N. Wareing
Con
Dame Angela Watkinson
Con
Sir John Whittingdale
Maldon
LD
Mr Mark Williams
Lab
Mrs Betty Williams
LD
Roger Williams
LD
Stephen Williams
LD
Lord Willis of Knaresborough
LD
Jenny Willott
Con
Mr David Wilshire
Con
Ann Winterton
Con
Sir Nicholas Winterton
Lab
Mike Wood
Lab
Dr Tony Wright
Con
Sir Jeremy Wright
Kenilworth and Southam
Lab
Derek Wyatt
LD
Richard Younger-Ross

Contains Parliamentary information licensed under the Open Parliament Licence v3.0.