PARLIAMENTARY EARLY DAY MOTION
COMPULSORY IDENTITY CARDS (7 February 2002)

Motion Details

That this House is concerned by proposals to make ownership of a state identity card compulsory; believes that, since cards would be largely pointless unless everyone carried them, there would be inexorable pressure to make it compulsory to carry them or to empower police to arrest anyone without a card and escort them to wherever it was kept and that even then it would be of little use on tackling crime since police rarely have problems identifying suspects against whom there is evidence; also believes that any attempts to control illegal immigration by requiring people who 'look like immigrants' to prove their identity would be intolerably divisive and that forcing people to put personal information on their card would put their privacy at risk; further believes that it would give the state excessive power which could be abused and that the estimated ú1 billion cost would be better spent on more police; and further believes that such a compulsory identity card is different in kind from voluntary cards which enable people to exercise a personal entitlement such as access to their bank account or club premises.

Sponsored by:
Lord Lilley (Conservative)

EDMS Sponsor By Party

Party
Votes
%
 
Labour
25
33%
 
 
Liberal Democrat
24
32%
 
 
Conservative
16
21%
 
 
Independent
5
7%
 
 
Scottish National Party
2
3%
 
 
Plaid Cymru
2
3%
 
 
Non-affiliated
1
1%
 
Sponsor List (75 sponsors)
Party
Member
Constituency
Lab
Ms Diane Abbott
Hackney North and Stoke Newington
Con
Mr Richard Bacon
LD
John Barrett
Lab
Andrew Bennett
Lab
Mr Harold Best
Con
Sir Peter Bottomley
LD
Tom Brake
LD
Lord Burnett
LD
Paul Burstow
LD
Sir Vince Cable
LD
Mrs Patsy Calton
Con
Lord Cameron of Chipping Norton
LD
Lord Campbell of Pittenweem
LD
Mr Alistair Carmichael
Orkney and Shetland
Lab
Mr Tony Clarke
Lab
Harry Cohen
Lab
Mr Tony Colman
Ind
Jeremy Corbyn
Islington North
LD
Lord Cotter
Lab
Mr Ian Davidson
Lab
Mr Terry Davis
Lab
Mr Andrew Dismore
LD
Sue Doughty
Con
Mr Peter Duncan
Lab
Bill Etherington
SNP
Annabelle Ewing
Con
Mark Field
Con
Mr Adrian Flook
LD
Lord Foster of Bath
Lab
Mr Neil Gerrard
Con
Nick Gibb
LD
Sandra Gidley
Con
Lord Goodman of Wycombe
LD
Matthew Green
Ind
Mr Mike Hancock
LD
Dr Evan Harris
LD
Sir Nick Harvey
Con
Mr David Heathcoat-Amory
Con
Mr Mark Hoban
LD
Paul Holmes
Ind
Mr Eric Illsley
Lab
Glenda Jackson
LD
Lord Jones of Cheltenham
Lab
Lynne Jones
LD
Mr David Laws
Con
Lord Lilley (Sponsor)
PC
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
Lab
Rob Marris
Ind
John McDonnell
Hayes and Harlington
Lab
Mr Kevin McNamara
Con
Dr Andrew Murrison
South West Wiltshire
Lab
Mr Mike O'Brien
LD
Lembit Öpik
Lab
Albert Owen
Con
Mr Mark Prisk
LD
Mr Alan Reid
LD
Mr David Rendel
Lab
Mr Geoffrey Robinson
Con
Andrew Rosindell
Romford
LD
Mr Adrian Sanders
Lab
Alan Simpson
Lab
Mr Dennis Skinner
LD
Lord Stunell
Con
Lord Swire
Lab
David Taylor
Ind
Dr Richard Taylor
Con
Sir Teddy Taylor
PC
Mr Simon Thomas
Baroness Tonge
Lab
Dr Rudi Vis
SNP
Mike Weir
LD
Roger Williams
Lab
Mr David Winnick
Lab
Mike Wood
Lab
Mr Jimmy Wray

Contains Parliamentary information licensed under the Open Parliament Licence v3.0.