PARLIAMENTARY EARLY DAY MOTION
RADIOTHERAPY INJURY AFTER BREAST CANCER (8 December 2000)

Motion Details

That this House believes there is a moral obligation for the Government to provide an ex gratia payment for women who have been injured by their radiotherapy treatment; recognises that in the past women were not warned of the dangerous risks before their radiotherapy treatments, were not given counselling after them and that the treatment was administered without informed consent being sought or given; understands radiotherapy injuries can include painful, untreatable and permanent injuries such as the paralysis of an arm or spontaneous bone fractures; notes that no compensation has been paid since EDM 512 (COURAGE campaign for patients with radiotherapy damage) was tabled in December 1997; asks the Secretary of State for Health to empower the Health Service Commissioner to recommend the award of ex gratia payments in appropriate circumstances, as proposed by the Health Select Committee in 1999; and urges the Department of Health to look again at the provision of an arbitration system to provide no-fault compensation for exceptional cases where the NHS is responsible for non-negligent harm.

Sponsored by:
Ed Davey (Liberal Democrat)

EDMS Sponsor By Party

Party
Votes
%
 
Labour
100
62%
 
 
Liberal Democrat
24
15%
 
 
Conservative
16
10%
 
 
Independent
8
5%
 
 
Ulster Unionist Party
5
3%
 
 
Plaid Cymru
3
2%
 
 
Non-affiliated
2
1%
 
 
Not Available
1
1%
 
 
Democratic Unionist Party
1
1%
 
 
Social Democratic & Labour Party
1
1%
 
 
The Independent Group for Change
1
1%
 
Sponsor List (162 sponsors)
Party
Member
Constituency
Lord Allan of Hallam
Con
Sir David Amess
Lab
John Austin
Lab
Mr Adrian Bailey
Lab
Mr Harry Barnes
Lab
Mr Nigel Beard
UUP
Mr Roy Beggs
LD
Lord Beith
Ind
Mr Martin Bell
Lab
Mr Tony Benn
Lab
Roger Berry
Lab
Mr Harold Best
Con
Sir Peter Bottomley
LD
Tom Brake
LD
Dr Peter Brand
Con
Sir Julian Brazier
LD
Mr Colin Breed
Lab
Mr Russell Brown
Lab
Ms Karen Buck
Lab
Colin Burgon
Con
Sir Simon Burns
Lab
Christine Butler
LD
Sir Vince Cable
LD
Lord Campbell of Pittenweem
Lab
Mr Ronnie Campbell
Lab
Sir Alan Campbell
Tynemouth
Lab
Martin Caton
Lab
Mr Ian Cawsey
LD
Lord Chidgey
Lab
Mr Michael Clapham
Con
Dr Michael Clark
Lab
Mrs Helen Clark
Lab
Ann Clwyd
Lab
Harry Cohen
Lab
Michael Connarty
Lab
Frank Cook
Ind
Jeremy Corbyn
Islington North
Lab
Tom Cox
Lab
Sir David Crausby
Lab
Mrs Ann Cryer
Lab
John Cummings
Lab
Mr Lawrence Cunliffe
Lab
Mr Jim Cunningham
LD
Ed Davey (Sponsor)
Kingston and Surbiton
Lab
Valerie Davey
Lab
Mr Ian Davidson
Lab
Denzil Davies
Lab
Mr Terry Davis
Lab
Mrs Janet Dean
Lab
Mr Andrew Dismore
Lab
Jim Dobbin
Ind
Sir Jeffrey M Donaldson
Lab
Dr David Drew
Lab
Mr Huw Edwards
Lab
Jeff Ennis
Lab
Bill Etherington
Lab
Barbara Follett
IGC
Mike Gapes
LD
Andrew George
St Ives
Lab
Dr Ian Gibson
LD
Sandra Gidley
Lab
Linda Gilroy
Lab
Dr Norman Godman
Lab
Baroness Golding
LD
Mr Donald Gorrie
Lab
Mr Win Griffiths
Lab
Mr John Gunnell
LD
Sir Nick Harvey
LD
Mr David Heath
Lab
Mr Ivan Henderson
Ind
Kelvin Hopkins
Con
Lord Horam
LD
Simon Hughes
SDLP
Mr John Hume
DUP
Mr Andrew Hunter
Lab
Mr Alan Hurst
Ind
Mr Eric Illsley
Lab
Glenda Jackson
Con
Sir Geoffrey Johnson Smith
LD
Lord Jones of Cheltenham
Lab
Lynne Jones
PC
Mr Ieuan Wyn Jones
Lab
Ms Jenny Jones
Lab
Alan Keen
LD
Mr Paul Keetch
Lab
Mr Peter Kilfoyle
Lab
Ms Tess Kingham
Lab
Dr Ashok Kumar
Lab
Dr Stephen Ladyman
Lab
David Lepper
Ind
Mr Ken Livingstone
LD
Lord Livsey of Talgarth
PC
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
Lab
Mr Andrew Love
Lab
Andrew Mackinlay
Lord Maginnis of Drumglass
Lab
Alice Mahon
Ind
Mr Paul Marsden
Lab
Mr John McAllion
Lab
Chris McCafferty
Ind
John McDonnell
Hayes and Harlington
Lab
Mr Kevin McNamara
Lab
Mr Tony McWalter
Lab
Sir Alan Meale
Lab
Mr Bill Michie
LD
Mrs Ray Michie
Lab
Andrew Miller
Lab
Austin Mitchell
Lab
Laura Moffatt
Lab
Julie Morgan
Lab
Mr George Mudie
Con
Mr Patrick Nicholls
Lab
Lord O'Neill of Clackmannan
Lab
Diana Organ
Lab
Linda Perham
Lab
Mr Peter Pike
Lab
Mr Gordon Prentice
Lab
Bill Rammell
Lab
Syd Rapson
Con
Mr Laurence Robertson
Lab
Mr Geoffrey Robinson
Con
Dame Marion Roe
Lab
Mr Allan Rogers
UUP
Mr William Ross
Lab
Dame Joan Ruddock
LD
Sir Bob Russell
Lab
Martin Salter
LD
Mr Adrian Sanders
Lab
Phil Sawford
LD
Mr Brian Sedgemore
Con
Baroness Shephard of Northwold
Lab
Alan Simpson
Lab
Mr Marsha Singh
UUP
The Rev Martin Smyth
Lab
Lord Snape
Lab
Mr Gerry Steinberg
Lab
Ian Stewart
Lab
Mr David Stewart
Lab
Mr Paul Stinchcombe
Lab
Dr Gavin Strang
Con
Sir Desmond Swayne
New Forest West
LD
Lord Taylor of Goss Moor
Con
Mr John D. Taylor
Lab
Ms Dari Taylor
UUP
Mr William Thompson
Baroness Tonge
Lab
Jon Trickett
Normanton and Hemsworth
Lab
Dr Desmond Turner
Lab
Stephen Twigg
LD
Lord Tyler
Lab
Mr Bill Tynan
Lab
Dr Rudi Vis
UUP
Sir Cecil Walker
Con
Mr Bowen Wells
PC
Lord Wigley
Con
Mr John Wilkinson
Lab
Mrs Betty Williams
LD
Lord Willis of Knaresborough
Lab
Mr David Winnick
Con
Ann Winterton
Lab
Mike Wood
Lab
Derek Wyatt

Contains Parliamentary information licensed under the Open Parliament Licence v3.0.