PARLIAMENTARY EARLY DAY MOTION
HOUSING BENEFIT AND COUNCIL RENTS (17 December 1998)

Motion Details

That this House deplores the unfair anomaly of relatively low income council tenants where an increasing number of councils, currently over 90 per cent., are compelled to divert council house rents into rent rebates for council tenants as a result of the Local Government and Housing Act 1990; condemns the totally unacceptable principle that the poor should subsidise the poorest in this way, particularly since private housing association tenants are not asked to do the same because their housing benefit is paid by the Exchequer so that in effect council tenants are paying twice, once through taxes to pay the housing benefit of all tenants be they housing association, private or council, and secondly through their rent to pay the housing benefit of the poorest of their fellow tenants; and urges the Government to end this practice which asks council tenants to pay both rents and taxes to fund benefit payments when it introduces resource accounting by returning funding of rent rebate to central government thereby enabling the ú1.3 billion rent money released to be redistributed fairly like capital receipts and be used for council housing expenditure to which it should be dedicated.

Sponsored by:
Austin Mitchell (Labour)

EDMS Sponsor By Party

Party
Votes
%
 
Labour
126
71%
 
 
Liberal Democrat
30
17%
 
 
Independent
9
5%
 
 
Plaid Cymru
4
2%
 
 
Conservative
3
2%
 
 
Non-affiliated
2
1%
 
 
Scottish National Party
1
1%
 
 
Not Available
1
1%
 
 
Ulster Unionist Party
1
1%
 
 
Democratic Unionist Party
1
1%
 
Sponsor List (178 sponsors)
Party
Member
Constituency
Lord Allan of Hallam
Lab
Mr Joe Ashton
Lab
John Austin
LD
Norman Baker
LD
Jackie Ballard
Lab
Mr Harry Barnes
Lab
Mr Nigel Beard
LD
Lord Beith
Ind
Mr Martin Bell
Lab
Hilary Benn
Leeds South
Lab
Mr Tony Benn
Lab
Andrew Bennett
Lab
Mr Joe Benton
Lab
Mr Gerry Bermingham
Lab
Roger Berry
Lab
Mr Harold Best
Con
Sir Peter Bottomley
Lab
Peter Bradley
LD
Tom Brake
LD
Dr Peter Brand
LD
Mr Colin Breed
Lab
Ms Karen Buck
LD
Paul Burstow
Lab
Christine Butler
LD
Sir Vince Cable
Lab
Mr Ronnie Campbell
Ind
Dennis Canavan
Lab
Mr Jamie Cann
Lab
Martin Caton
Lab
Mr Ian Cawsey
Ind
Mr David Chaytor
LD
Lord Chidgey
Lab
Mr Michael Clapham
Lab
Mrs Helen Clark
Lab
Paul Clark
Lab
Mr Tony Clarke
Lab
Harry Cohen
Lab
Mr Iain Coleman
Lab
Michael Connarty
Lab
Lord Corbett of Castle Vale
LD
Lord Cotter
Lab
Jim Cousins
Lab
Sir David Crausby
Lab
Mrs Ann Cryer
Lab
Mr Lawrence Cunliffe
Lab
Mr Jim Cunningham
Lab
Mrs Claire Curtis-Thomas
PC
Cynog Dafis
LD
Ed Davey
Kingston and Surbiton
Lab
Valerie Davey
Lab
Mr Ian Davidson
Lab
Denzil Davies
Lab
Mr Terry Davis
Lab
Mrs Janet Dean
Lab
Mr Andrew Dismore
Lab
Jim Dobbin
Lab
Dr David Drew
Lab
Mrs Gwyneth Dunwoody
Lab
Maria Eagle
Liverpool Garston
Lab
Mr Huw Edwards
Lab
Clive Efford
Eltham and Chislehurst
Lab
Jeff Ennis
Lab
Bill Etherington
LD
Lord Fearn
Lab
Jim Fitzpatrick
Lab
Paul Flynn
Lab
Barbara Follett
LD
Lord Foster of Bath
Lab
Michael Jabez Foster
Lab
Mr Michael Foster
Lab
Mrs Maria Fyfe
Lab
Barry Gardiner
Brent West
LD
Andrew George
St Ives
Lab
Dr Ian Gibson
Con
Mr Christopher Gill
Lab
Dr Norman Godman
Lab
Mr Roger Godsiff
Lab
Baroness Golding
LD
Mr Donald Gorrie
Lab
Jane Griffiths
Lab
Patrick Hall
Ind
Mr Mike Hancock
LD
Dr Evan Harris
LD
Sir Nick Harvey
Lab
John Healey
Rawmarsh and Conisbrough
LD
Mr David Heath
Ind
Kelvin Hopkins
LD
Simon Hughes
Lab
Dr Brian Iddon
Ind
Mr Eric Illsley
Lab
Mr Robert Jackson
LD
Lord Jones of Cheltenham
Lab
Lynne Jones
PC
Mr Ieuan Wyn Jones
Lab
Mr Martyn Jones
LD
Mr Paul Keetch
Lab
Mr Piara S Khabra
Lab
Baroness King of Bow
Lab
Andy King
Lab
Ms Tess Kingham
Lab
Dr Ashok Kumar
Lab
Dr Stephen Ladyman
Lab
Mrs Jackie Lawrence
Lab
Mr Bob Laxton
Lab
David Lepper
Lab
Mr Terry Lewis
Lab
Martin Linton
Ind
Mr Ken Livingstone
LD
Lord Livsey of Talgarth
PC
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
Lab
Mr Andrew Love
Lab
Alice Mahon
Lab
Gordon Marsden
Mr Robert McCartney
Ind
John McDonnell
Hayes and Harlington
Lab
Mr Tony McWalter
Lab
Mr Bill Michie
Lab
Austin Mitchell (Sponsor)
Lab
Laura Moffatt
Lab
Julie Morgan
SNP
Mr Alasdair Morgan
Lab
Mr Chris Mullin
Lab
Dr Doug Naysmith
Lab
Mr Edward O'Hara
LD
Mr Mark Oaten
LD
Lembit Öpik
Lab
Diana Organ
Lab
Ian Pearson
Lab
Mr Peter Pike
Lab
Mr James Plaskitt
Lab
Mr Kerry Pollard
Lab
Sir Raymond Powell
Lab
Gwyn Prosser
Lab
Bill Rammell
Lab
Syd Rapson
LD
Mr David Rendel
DUP
Mr Peter Robinson
Lab
Mr Allan Rogers
Con
Mr Andrew Rowe
Lab
Christine Russell
LD
Sir Bob Russell
Lab
Martin Salter
LD
Mr Adrian Sanders
Lab
Mr Malcolm Savidge
Lab
Phil Sawford
Lab
Ms Debra Shipley
Lab
Alan Simpson
Lab
Mr Marsha Singh
Lab
Mr Dennis Skinner
LD
Angela Smith
UUP
The Rev Martin Smyth
Lab
Lord Snape
Lab
Helen Southworth
Lab
Dr Phyllis Starkey
Lab
Mr Gerry Steinberg
Lab
Mr George Stevenson
Lab
Mr Paul Stinchcombe
Lab
Roger Stott
Lab
Dr Gavin Strang
LD
Lord Stunell
Lab
David Taylor
Lab
Gareth Thomas
Lab
Mr Mark Todd
Baroness Tonge
Lab
Mr Paul Truswell
Lab
Dr Desmond Turner
Lab
Dr Rudi Vis
Lab
Joan Walley
Ind
Mr Robert N. Wareing
PC
Lord Wigley
Lab
Dr Alan Williams
Lab
Mrs Betty Williams
LD
Lord Willis of Knaresborough
Lab
Mr David Winnick
Lab
Mrs Audrey Wise
Lab
Mike Wood
Lab
Dr Tony Wright
Lab
Derek Wyatt

Contains Parliamentary information licensed under the Open Parliament Licence v3.0.