PARLIAMENTARY EARLY DAY MOTION
PENSIONS CLAWBACK (18 April 1999)

Motion Details

That this House believes that the practice of integrating occupational pensions with the state pension, commonly known as clawback, which allows employers to deduct a significant proportion of their employees' pension, affecting up to 2.5 million pensioners across the United Kingdom and hitting the lowest paid and part-time workers hardest, is unfair, as pensioners who have paid national insurance contributions all their working lives are entitled to benefit from the provisions intended by Government to be available to all; and believes that the Government should legislate to phase out this practice, following the example set by the Republic of Ireland where a recently introduced Bill, which has the full support of the Irish Government, states that the amount deducted from occupational pension payments by trustees of pension schemes cannot increase when the amount of the state pension is increased, effectively freezing the amount which can be deducted.

Sponsored by:
Mr Kerry Pollard (Labour)

EDMS Sponsor By Party

Party
Votes
%
 
Labour
138
68%
 
 
Liberal Democrat
26
13%
 
 
Conservative
12
6%
 
 
Independent
9
4%
 
 
Ulster Unionist Party
5
2%
 
 
Plaid Cymru
4
2%
 
 
Social Democratic & Labour Party
3
1%
 
 
Not Available
2
1%
 
 
Non-affiliated
2
1%
 
 
Democratic Unionist Party
2
1%
 
 
Scottish National Party
1
0%
 
Sponsor List (204 sponsors)
Party
Member
Constituency
Lab
Ms Diane Abbott
Hackney North and Stoke Newington
Lord Allan of Hallam
Lab
Mr Joe Ashton
Lab
Ms Candy Atherton
Lab
Charlotte Atkins
Lab
John Austin
LD
Norman Baker
DUP
Lord Bannside
Lab
Mr Harry Barnes
UUP
Mr Roy Beggs
LD
Lord Beith
Ind
Mr Martin Bell
Lab
Hilary Benn
Leeds South
Lab
Mr Gerry Bermingham
Lab
Mr Harold Best
Lab
Liz Blackman
Lab
Mr Bob Blizzard
Lab
Mr David S. Borrow
Con
Lord Brady of Altrincham
LD
Tom Brake
LD
Dr Peter Brand
LD
Mr Colin Breed
Lab
Mr Russell Brown
Lab
Ms Karen Buck
Lab
Colin Burgon
LD
Paul Burstow
Lab
Christine Butler
LD
Sir Vince Cable
Lab
Mr Ronnie Campbell
Lab
Sir Alan Campbell
Tynemouth
Ind
Dennis Canavan
Lab
Mr Jamie Cann
Lab
Martin Caton
Lab
Mr Ian Cawsey
Ind
Mr David Chaytor
LD
Lord Chidgey
Lab
Mr Michael Clapham
Con
Dr Michael Clark
Lab
Mrs Helen Clark
Lab
Mr Eric Clarke
Lab
Mr Tony Clarke
Lab
Ann Clwyd
Lab
Harry Cohen
Con
Michael Colvin
Lab
Michael Connarty
Lab
Frank Cook
Ind
Jeremy Corbyn
Islington North
LD
Lord Cotter
Lab
Jim Cousins
Lab
Tom Cox
Lab
Lord Cryer
Lab
Mrs Ann Cryer
Lab
John Cummings
Lab
Mr Lawrence Cunliffe
Lab
Mr Jim Cunningham
Lab
Mrs Claire Curtis-Thomas
PC
Cynog Dafis
LD
Ed Davey
Kingston and Surbiton
Lab
Valerie Davey
Lab
Mr Ian Davidson
Lab
Denzil Davies
Lab
Mr Ron Davies
Lab
Mr Terry Davis
Lab
Mrs Janet Dean
Lab
Jim Dobbin
Lab
Dr David Drew
Lab
Mrs Gwyneth Dunwoody
Lab
Maria Eagle
Liverpool Garston
Lab
Jeff Ennis
Lab
Bill Etherington
SNP
Mrs Margaret Ewing
LD
Lord Fearn
Lab
Jim Fitzpatrick
Con
Lord Flight
Lab
Paul Flynn
UUP
Clifford Forsythe
LD
Lord Foster of Bath
Lab
Lord Foster of Bishop Auckland
Lab
Michael Jabez Foster
Lab
Mrs Maria Fyfe
LD
Andrew George
St Ives
Lab
Mr Neil Gerrard
Lab
Dr Ian Gibson
Lab
Dr Norman Godman
Lab
Baroness Golding
LD
Mr Donald Gorrie
Con
Mr John Greenway
Lab
Mr Win Griffiths
Lab
John Grogan
Lab
Patrick Hall
Lab
Fabian Hamilton
Leeds North East
Ind
Mr Mike Hancock
LD
Dr Evan Harris
Lab
Mr Ivan Henderson
Lab
Stephen Hesford
Lab
Mr David Hinchliffe
Lab
Mr Jim Hood
Ind
Kelvin Hopkins
Con
Lord Horam
SDLP
Mr John Hume
Lab
Dr Brian Iddon
Ind
Mr Eric Illsley
LD
Lord Jones of Cheltenham
Lab
Lynne Jones
PC
Mr Ieuan Wyn Jones
Lab
Mr Martyn Jones
LD
Mr Paul Keetch
Lab
Mr David Kidney
Lab
Andy King
Con
Julie Kirkbride
Lab
Dr Ashok Kumar
Lab
Dr Stephen Ladyman
Lab
Mr Bob Laxton
Lab
David Lepper
Lab
Mr Terry Lewis
Ind
Mr Ken Livingstone
LD
Lord Livsey of Talgarth
PC
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
Lab
Mr Andrew Love
Lord Maginnis of Drumglass
SDLP
Mr Seamus Mallon
Lab
Gordon Marsden
Con
Mr Michael Mates
Lab
Lord Maxton
Lab
Mr John McAllion
Lab
Steve McCabe
Ind
John McDonnell
Hayes and Harlington
SDLP
Mr Eddie McGrady
Lab
Mr Tony McWalter
Lab
Mr Bill Michie
Lab
Austin Mitchell
Lab
Laura Moffatt
LD
Michael Moore
Lab
Julie Morgan
Lab
Mr Chris Mullin
Lab
Dr Doug Naysmith
Lab
Mr Edward O'Hara
Lab
Lord O'Neill of Clackmannan
LD
Mr Mark Oaten
Lab
Mr Bill Olner
Lab
Diana Organ
Lab
Sandra Osborne
Lab
Dr Nick Palmer
Lab
Lord Pendry
Lab
Mr Peter Pike
Lab
Mr Kerry Pollard (Sponsor)
Lab
Stephen Pound
Lab
Gwyn Prosser
Lab
Bill Rammell
Con
Lord Randall of Uxbridge
Lab
Syd Rapson
DUP
Mr Peter Robinson
Lab
Mr Allan Rogers
Lab
Mr Ernie Ross
UUP
Mr William Ross
Lab
Dame Joan Ruddock
Lab
Christine Russell
LD
Sir Bob Russell
LD
Mr Adrian Sanders
Lab
Mr Malcolm Savidge
Lab
Phil Sawford
Lab
Alan Simpson
Lab
Mr Marsha Singh
Lab
Mr Dennis Skinner
LD
Angela Smith
Lab
Geraldine Smith
UUP
The Rev Martin Smyth
Lab
Lord Snape
Lab
Dr Phyllis Starkey
Lab
Mr Gerry Steinberg
Lab
Mr George Stevenson
Lab
Ian Stewart
Lab
Mr Paul Stinchcombe
Lab
Dr Howard Stoate
Lab
Roger Stott
Lab
Graham Stringer
Blackley and Middleton South
LD
Lord Stunell
Con
Sir Desmond Swayne
New Forest West
LD
Lord Taylor of Goss Moor
Lab
David Taylor
Lab
Lord Temple-Morris
Baroness Tonge
Lab
Mr Paul Truswell
Lab
Dr Desmond Turner
Lab
Dr Rudi Vis
UUP
Sir Cecil Walker
Lab
Joan Walley
Mr Charles Wardle
Lab
Lord Watts
Lab
Brian White
Lab
Malcolm Wicks
PC
Lord Wigley
Con
Mr John Wilkinson
Lab
Dr Alan Williams
Lab
Mrs Betty Williams
LD
Lord Willis of Knaresborough
Con
Sir Nicholas Winterton
Lab
Mrs Audrey Wise
Lab
Mike Wood
Lab
Tony Worthington
Lab
Mr Jimmy Wray
Lab
Dr Tony Wright
Lab
Mr Anthony Wright
Lab
Derek Wyatt

Contains Parliamentary information licensed under the Open Parliament Licence v3.0.